Cupped hands holding a mound of biochar above a field

The biochar sector hits a regulatory roadblock

Sofie HviidBy Sofie Hviid
Journalist, Klimajournalisterne

The road ahead for Denmark’s biochar industry has taken another detour. The country’s DKK 10 billion subsidy scheme has been postponed, but the money is still there and the political commitment remains. For now, the industry has to keep going while the government gets the regulatory framework in place.

There was a collective sigh from Denmark’s biochar industry on Monday, 21 September.

That was the day it became clear that the long-awaited government tender designed to create a market for CO₂ removal through pyrolysis and biochar would not go ahead as planned in 2027.

The Ministry of Climate, Energy and Utilities has postponed the planned DKK 10 billion subsidy scheme indefinitely.

On the surface, this looks like a serious setback for an industry that has spent years waiting for political ambitions to translate into actual demand.

But the picture is more nuanced. The government has not abandoned biochar. The money remains allocated in the budget framework, and the political decision to use biochar as part of Denmark’s climate strategy has not changed.

What is missing are the rules that need to be in place before the tender can go ahead.

The rules have to come first

The ministry has pointed to two main reasons for the postponement. First, there must be full documentation of environmental and health impacts before a public support scheme can be launched. Second, market consultations have indicated a risk that there could be few or even no bids.

The two issues are closely connected.

Companies need to know which environmental rules will apply to biochar used on agricultural land before they can enter binding agreements with farmers and calculate the economics of their projects. The tender also includes penalties if companies fail to deliver the promised CO₂ removals.

“If you want bidders for a tender, you need to know which environmental rules you are bidding under,” says Morten Heick of the industry association Pyrolysis Denmark.

According to Heick, the universities delivered their measurement data on time, while the subsequent processing by the Danish Environmental Protection Agency has taken longer than expected.

The 192 million DKK that was meant to be spent in 2027 has been reallocated to compensate farmers for using fertilizer. That money will not return to the pool, which Morten Heick calls a disappointment.

“We naturally find it unfortunate that climate and environmental technology is being cut and delayed in order to compensate for that very same thing. As we say in Danish, it is a bit like wetting your trousers to keep warm.”

A delay – not a cancellation

That distinction matters. The environmental regulations governing the application of biochar to agricultural land were originally expected to enter into force in January 2027. They are now expected in October 2027. There is still no new date for the tender itself.

The immediate problem is therefore primarily one of timing. The industry will have to wait longer for the major source of demand expected to finance the next wave of plants.

Politically, however, the underlying commitment remains unchanged.

And the industry is no longer starting from scratch. According to Pyrolysis Denmark, there is already capacity to remove almost 55,000 tonnes of CO₂ per year across 14 plants, all privately financed.

That is important. Denmark now has commercial plants, private investment and an emerging industry. But the sector has not yet reached the point where the government-backed market can support the next major expansion.

That is the gap the postponement exposes.

The delay has also drawn criticism from outside the industry. Jørgen E. Olesen, one of the leading researchers in the field of green transition of the agricultural sector from Aarhus University, has described the postponement as problematic, arguing that a “zero tolerance” approach to new technologies could put agricultural climate targets at risk.

A test of patience

For companies, the delay is nevertheless a real challenge.

Vrejlev Energi in Vrå is among the companies having to postpone the transition to full-scale operations because of the uncertainty. Other producers will have to keep existing plants running, find alternative markets for their biochar or look abroad, while keeping a close eye on cash flow.

The delay creates ripple effects across the entire ecosystem: startups face longer runways before a domestic offtake market materialises, investors face increased timing risk on plant-stage deals, and voluntary credit and biochar buyers suddenly have access to more domestic supply seeking immediate buyers.

The delay also raises questions about how the DKK 10 billion should ultimately be distributed. Pyrolysis Denmark has suggested dividing the subsidy into several tender rounds. That could allow companies to build the first plants, gain experience and compete for subsequent contracts, potentially creating stronger competition for public funds.

Whether the government will choose that model remains undecided.

In the longer term, Denmark will need demand beyond its own borders if the industry is to grow.

Biochar was not included in the European Commission’s first proposal for revising the emissions trading system, which covered only BioCCS and DACCS. A later draft reportedly includes biochar, but the final legislation has yet to be agreed.

For now, however, the Danish subsidy scheme remains far more important to the industry.

Keeping your nerve

The coming months are therefore less about proving that biochar has a future and more about getting the practical framework in place.

In the meantime, the industry has to keep its operations and finances under control.

“You obviously have to live within your means and make sure you don’t invest too heavily and burn through too much money. But you really have to keep your nerve in this industry,” says Heick.

Even though it is vital for the industry with the subsidy scheme, there are other options to be explored in the meantime. One alternative source of revenue is the voluntary carbon market, where companies can buy certified carbon removal credits to compensate for their emissions.

Another source of support is public funding for research and innovation. EU programmes provide grants for developing and scaling new pyrolysis technologies, allowing companies to finance technological improvements even before a large commercial market is established.

Ten years ago, pyrolysis in Denmark was still largely at the concept stage. Today, there are commercial plants, growing production capacity and a role for biochar in the Green Tripartite agreement, where the technology is expected to contribute up to 0.3 million tonnes of CO₂e in 2030.

That is the foundation the industry now has to build on. The main challenge is no longer to prove that Danish pyrolysis can exist. It is to get regulation, capital and demand to move forward together.

The road to a major biochar market has become a little longer. With timelines uncertain, sharing information between producers, buyers, researchers, and investors matters more than ever. But the road has not been closed.

 

The Rockstart Biochar Network was created with the support of the Danish government’s GUDP – Green Development and Demonstration Program. The initiative aims to advance regenerative agriculture and promote the use of biochar within all stakeholders in the ecosystem. Biochar, produced through pyrolysis, can persist in soils for centuries, enhancing fertility and capturing carbon dioxide. The Network supports Denmark’s climate change mitigation strategies, including improving the fertility of coarse sandy soils and preparing for the government’s 2027 biochar objectives, which encompass CO₂ taxation policies and the integration of climate technologies. Participation in the Biochar Network is free and open to all stakeholders.

Join the Biochar Network if you would like to learn more about Denmark’s biochar ecosystem.